16.11.1957 Chester City - Gateshead FC 4:3
Clapton FC - Queens Park Rangers 1:1
Bath City FC - Exeter City 2:1
Dorchester Town - Wycombe Wanderers 3:2
Rochdale AFC - Darlington FC 0:2
Reading FC - Swindon Town 1:0
Wisbech Town - Colchester United 1:0
Gillingham FC - Gorleston FC 10:1
Wrexham AFC - Accrington Stanley 0:1
Bishop Auckland FC - Bury FC 0:0
Tranmere Rovers - Witton Albion 2:1
Stockport County - Barrow AFC 2:1
Trowbridge Town - Southend United 0:2
Northampton Town - Newport County 3:0
Coventry City - Walthamstow Ave 1:0
Brighton & Hove Albion - Walsall FC 2:1
Norwich City - Redhill FC 6:1
Plymouth Argyle - Watford FC 6:2
Bradford City - Scarborough FC 6:0
Millwall FC - Brentford FC 1:0
Hull City - Crewe Alexandra 2:1
Carlisle United - Rhyl FC 5:1
Oldham Athletic - Bradford Park Avenue 2:0
Hartlepools United - Prescot Cables FC 5:0
Scunthorpe United - Goole Town 2:1
Mansfield Town - Halifax Town 2:0
Port Vale FC - Shrewsbury Town 2:1
Margate FC - Crystal Palace 2:3
Durham City AFC - Spalding United 3:1
Southport FC - Wigan Athletic 1:2
Oswestry Town FC - Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic 1:5
Workington AFC - Crook Town AFC 8:1
York City - Chesterfield FC 1:0
Aldershot FC - Worcester City 0:0
Guildford City - Yeovil Town 2:2
Newport IOW - Hereford United 0:3
Boston United - Billingham Synthonia 5:2
Peterborough United - Torquay United 3:3
South Shields - Frickley Colliery Athletic 3:2
Walton & Hersham - Southampton FC 1:6
Entscheidungsspiele
18.11.1957 Queens Park Rangers - Clapton FC 3:1
19.11.1957 Bury FC - Bishop Auckland FC 4:1
20.11.1957 Torquay United - Peterborough United 1:0
21.11.1957 Worcester City - Aldershot FC 2:2
Yeovil Town - Guildford City 1:0
25.11.1957 Aldershot FC - Worcester City 3:2